To begin at the beginning.
1. Orders: Springtails can be divided into three groups:
- Globular springtails - rounded body shape
- Poduromorpha - equal sized body segments
- Entomobrymorpha - unequal sized body segments
2. Segmentation: The family Tomoceridae are part of the Entomobrymorpha. In the Tomoceridae, the third abdominal segment (abd3) is the longest, whereas in the Entomobryidae abd4 is longest. This characteristic is the first thing to look for and identifies a member of this family.
3. Antennae: All the Tomoceridae have relatively long antennae, but these are fragile and frequently break off so caution is needed unless all 4 antennal segments are present. In the Tomoceridae the third antennal segment (ant3) is longer than the others.
4. Antenna shape: All the species listed here were formerly in the genus Tomocerus but have now been split into two genera based on the shape of the antennae. If ant and ant4 taper towards the tip, go to 5. If the antennal segments do not taper significantly (nearly cylindrical), go to 6.
5. Genus Pogonognathellus:
In this genus, ant3 and ant4 taper towards the tip. The four anterior ocelli are in a diamond configuration.
Pogonognathellus longicornis - very common, widespread. The antennae are longer than the body (including the head). This species frequently curls ant3 and ant4 into a tight spiral:
In addition, the empodium is about 1.2 times as long as the claw due a thin filament on its tip (c.f. P. flavescens has no filament on any empodium):
Pogonognathellus flavescens - scarce, a more upland species.
The antennae taper but the intact antennae are shorter than the body (including the head):
Note that in spite of the name, yellow colouration is not characteristic for this species - see below. If in doubt (e.g. if the antennae are broken, check the empodium (see above) which is shorter than the claw.
6. Genus Tomocerus:
In this genus the antennal segments do not taper significantly (nearly cylindrical). The four anterior ocelli are in a square configuration.
Tomocerus minor - very common, widespread:
Separation this species from T. vulgaris requires examination of the spines on the dens (part of the furcula). In T. minor these are tridentate (three teeth):
Tomocerus vulgaris - very common, widespread:
Descriptions of this species sometimes refer to transverse bands of iridescent scales on the abdomen, but this is not a reliable characteristic for identification - see below. Separation this species from T. minor requires examination of the spines on the dens (part of the furcula). In T. vulgaris these are simple (no teeth on the spines, c.f. T. minor above):
There is one further UK species in this family, Tomocerus minutus, but this is extremely rare and has only been reported from mountain tops in Scotland and Wales. No specimens of this species exist, so it cannot be confirmed and should be ignored (unless you're on a mountain top and find a Tomocerus which does not look like any of the above).
The problem with scales
All the Tomoceridae are covered with dark and/or iridescent scales. At least, they start out with scales, but these are easily lost, revealing a golden body colour underneath. Scales and scale patterns are thus not a reliable identification characteristic in this group (and I should know, it's fooled me more than once!
Other Identification Guides: https://collembolla.blogspot.co.uk/p/identification-guides.html